From 1988 to present day, the church is administered by the Franciscan Friars, (T.O.R.) of the Third Order Regular of Saint Francis Penance
Rev. Damian-Vincent Amantia, T.O.R.
2012-Present
Rev. Cletus M.S. Watson, T.O.R.
2005-2012
Rev. Luke Robertson, T.O.R.
2003-2005
Rev. Bernardine J. Smith, T.O.R.
1988-2002
Historical pastors of Saint Mary Our Lady of Grace
Rev. John Colgan
1986-1988
Msgr. John P. McNulty
1972-1986
Msgr. James Gloeckler
1968-1972
Msgr. Patrick J. Donahue
1941-1968
Rev. James J. O'Riordan, STL
1920-1941